Rebuilding the Pipeline: Supply and Demand in the Skilled TradesMarch 11, 2019 When workforce analysts meet with businesses these days, the need for workers is usually the first topic of conversation. Across the country unemployment remains near record lows and the workforce is aging, which makes finding and retaining workers a top priority.
The manufacturers, builders, and other businesses in Oregon that rely on skilled tradespeople are particularly concerned with workforce development. They worry that they face additional hurdles when recruiting for these vital yet underappreciated roles.
Many believe that a push towards “college for all” drove the elimination of vocational programs that introduced young people to trades, limiting the pipeline of potential workers.
If so, rebuilding that pipeline will be a task that can’t be completed overnight. Even high wages and plentiful jobs aren’t always enough to overcome the gap in the perception of opportunities in skilled trades.
What Is a Skilled Trade?
There is no definitive list of skilled trades, but they share some characteristics. All skilled trades rely on a set of proficiencies learned over time, not just routine labor. For entry, candidates generally need some post-high school training or licensure, but not a bachelor’s degree.
Skilled trades are most commonly associated with the construction or manufacturing sectors. Examples include carpenters, electricians, and plumbers, each of which master a different aspect of the construction process.
For this article, I will focus on skilled trades in goods-producing industries for which apprenticeship is an option. An apprenticeship is a registered training program that allows trainees to earn a wage while learning trade skills.
Below is a list of apprenticible trades from the Oregon Bureau of Labor and Industries Apprenticeship and Training Division (ATD). Covering manufacturing, construction, and utilities, these occupations have established pathways for formal on-the-job training with a journey-level worker.
If you’d like to know more about apprenticeship opportunities please visit the ATD website for information on local programs.
Grandpa Is a Carpenter: Demand for Skilled Trades
From demographic trends to employer surveys, much of our data supports the view that the demand for skilled workers in the trades exceeds current supply.
Aging in the trades will open up opportunities for new employees as workers retire. In 2017, workers age 55 and older made up nearly a quarter of the construction and manufacturing workforce, a share that has increased by 15 percentage points in the last 25 years.
On top of demographic changes, industries employing the trades have been growing quickly. Construction has been one of the fastest growing industries in Oregon in recent years. Manufacturing employment has grown as well, and although the industry has yet to reach its pre-recession peak, hiring skilled tradespeople is a pain point for many manufacturers.
Statewide, trades command high wages. The table above compares the 2018 median wage for 30 trade occupations. Four out of five of these trades paid above the median wage for the state, and several paid more than double the median.
The Oregon Employment Department (OED) produces Occupational Prioritization for Training to help workforce partners invest in jobs with strong recent demand, wages, and expected growth, among other factors. Skilled trades such as carpenters, electricians, and HVAC installers show up near the top of the list, indicating an intersection between current business needs and worker opportunity.
Every year the Employment Department surveys businesses on their job vacancies and difficulty filling them. In the tight 2017 labor market, 64 percent of all jobs were difficult for employers to fill. For most of the largest trade occupations, between 80 to 100 percent of job vacancies were considered difficult to fill.
Trading Up: The Supply of Skilled Trades Workers
For those who train apprentices or prepare students, rebuilding the pipeline will require fresh thinking about how to make a program appealing and responsive to the needs of the workforce.
For example, many new trainees are young with relatively little work experience. An inviting and understanding work environment helps promote success for young people, who have had fewer opportunities to build work experience than previous generations.
Supporting underrepresented groups in skilled trades is another critical element of building a strong pipeline to the next generation.
Women provide a clear example of the difference a diverse pipeline could make. Women make up nearly half of the U.S. workforce, but represent very small portions of most skilled trades. Only one out of 20 machinists in the U.S. are female, and for several large trades the number is closer to one out of 100!
Female jobseekers are just as capable at learning and performing skilled trades, and employers that are able to recruit and retain women in these roles can instantly double their potential candidate pool.
When Do I Start?
If you want to learn more about a particular trade, check out our Occupation Profiles tool to see what growth and wages look like in your area and what kind of training and work conditions you can expect.
For example, search for “Carpenters" through the tool and scroll down through:
- A video showcasing what carpenters do
- Current job openings
- Wages across the state
- How many job openings OED projects over the next 10 years
- What type of companies carpenters work for, with links to look them up
- Information on the knowledge and abilities required and detailed job activities
- Where you can get training and the number of graduates from each program
Rebuilding the Pipeline
Limiting college debt and finding fulfilling work are increasingly central to our career decisions. In that context, it’s hard to ignore skilled trades, where trainees can get paid to learn and become part of a proud tradition of craftsmanship.
Still, a lack of parent and teacher familiarity with the opportunities available may lead them to steer students away from a career in the trades.
While the return on higher education is substantial on average, that’s not to say that every high school student is best served by pursuing a bachelor’s degree immediately after graduation.
Teachers, trainers, and parents can help by framing skilled trades and apprenticeships as another pathway to lifelong learning.
Skilled trades and college increasingly aren’t an either-or proposition anyway, but whether they go on to earn a bachelors’ degree or not, tradespeople are creative problem solvers that continually hone their craft, learning to respond to new technologies and trends.
Shifting our mindset about who can succeed in the trades is critical as well. Many paths bring people to a career in the trades, which often require an artistic touch and an analytical mind as well as mechanical skills.
In short, a true rebuilding of the pipeline requires broader community recognition of the value and opportunity in skilled trade work.